|
It is important in your proof to
get your documents into
evidence. This can be
accomplished in multiple ways
and the procedures for doing so
vary depending whether you are
in the district court or the
circuit court.
District Court
Procedure:
Courts and Judicial Proceedings
Article 10-104 provides in
pertinent part as follows: 60
days before trial
you must
serve pursuant to MD Rule 1-321a
notice of intent to offer
medical records and billing
statements and provide a list to
identify each record
and the
actual report/bill. Also you
must then file with the court a
Notice of Service which list and
identifies each record. Upon
completion of this task it is no
longer necessary for you to
bring in an expert to testify on
causation or that the medical
cost were fair reasonable and
necessary. Also, it is no longer
necessary to subpoena records
custodians to court to have the
records entered into evidence as
business records. It is
important to note that you can
use this same procedure in the
event your case is moved to the
circuit court on the defendant's
request for jury trial. Provided
you do not seek damages in
excess of the district court
limit of $25,000.00.
Circuit Court Procedure:
In the circuit court I use each
of the following methods:
1. Stipulation by Letter. I
simply forward a letter to
defendant's counsel enclosing
the medical records and bills
and ask that they agree that the
records and bills are authentic
and admissible. the stipulation
makes clear that the defendant's
counsel is not agreeing the
injury is casually connected or
that the cost are fair,
reasonable, and necessary. Only
that the records are what they
purport to be.
2. Request for Admission of
Fact: I do not generally find
that procedure functional. I
mention it because it is
available. However, generally in
my experience defendant's
counsel simply deny the
allegations. While I recognize a
failure to deny is an admission,
I have not yet seen a situation
where defendant's counsel fell
asleep at the wheel and failed
to deny. The rule has no teeth
as an unreasonable denial is not
subject to sanction. However you
can try to recover cost later.
3. Stipulation by Pre-trial
Statement. You will eventually
appear before the court for a
settlement conference. This is a
good time to get a stipulation
to your documents. Defendant's
counsel are in my experience
very professional attorneys.
They have no reason not to agree
the records are authentic.
Additionally, they have no
interest in appearing
unreasonable to the court. You
simply list your documents in
the pre-trial statement and
request the court to inquire if
defendant's counsel has any
objection to the admissibility.
4. Expert Testimony. When you
review further into the web
sight you will find a section on
expert testimony. You can also
use the expert as a way to get
your records into evidence. I
will mention the records will
come into evidence however using
this method the records do not
come in as proof of injury, they
come in only as the basis for
the expert's opinion. It is
necessary to have the expert
testify that he reviewed the
records, he relied upon their
content in reaching his opinion
and that it is customary in his
profession to rely upon such
information.
5. MD Rules 5-803(6) and
5-902(11) . This is my favorite
means of having records entered
into evidence. It requires
advanced planning as the records
properly must be supported by
the affidavit of the records
custodian. To proceed in this
manner order your records;
secure the custodian
certificates; forward the
medical records and bills to
defendant's counsel; and file a
notice of service to the court.
As an extra measure of safety I
also include with the filing a
list of the records by date and
service and cost incurred.
6. Subpoena. Simply subpoena the
records custodians to appear in
court with the records.
7. Defendant's Counsel Records
Deposition. Once defendant's
counsel issues the records
deposition I forward a letter
requesting a copy of the records
produced. You can follow receipt
of the documents with the
Request for Admission of Fact,
but again in practical terms
simply a call the defendant's
counsel should be sufficient to
get a stipulation. Again in my
experience the defendant bar has
always been very professional in
these situation. |